When you take part in a research study, usually only the researchers from that team can see your answers. This is controlled by university ethics committees (called IRBs in the USA).
What is data sharing?
Data sharing is when researchers remove any names of people and places from participants’ answers, and their answers are then put in a special online library called a ‘repository’.
Researchers from different teams can then ask the library for permission to use the data in their research. Sometimes it’s as simple as registering, and then you can see people’s answers, but other times you need to say exactly what you plan to do, and then you only get to see part of the answers that you need to answer the new research question.
The reason we are interested in this topic, is that some research funders (who allow us to do big research projects), and journals (who publish our research) say that data must be shared.
Why does this matter?
There can be benefits of data sharing, like allowing research to happen more quickly and for a lower cost.
But there are also worries about data sharing, like the new researchers misunderstanding what people meant.
In Autism research, we think this is really important because of negative views of Autism, including those held by key politicians in the USA who say they want to “cure” Autism.
For this reason, we think that it’s important that each person who takes part in Autism research (or research in general) gets asked if they want to be in the study, and when they say “yes” they are then given the opportunity to decide if they want to share their answers with other researchers. We call this “opt in consent”.
What did we do?
Aimee and the AM2M team worked with Prof Christina Nicolaidis who is the academic lead for the AASPIRE Outcomes project in the USA. On both of these studies, we gave Autistic people the chance to decide if they wanted to do data sharing.
When Autistic people were given the choice, did they want to do data sharing?
On the AM2M interview study, most people said no, with only 36% saying yes to sharing their answers with other groups of researchers. People who had menopause symptoms at the beginning of the study were more likely to say no. There was some evidence that those from white backgrounds (29%) were less likely to say yes to data sharing compared to those from racialised minorities (56%), but this association wasn’t there in all of the statistical tests we did.
People who said yes to data sharing in AM2M had relaxed and positive attitudes to data sharing and research in general. For trans and gender diverse participants, some used this as a reason to share their data – so their stories were heard – whilst others were more cautious because of transphobia, so decided not to share their data.
We also think that on AM2M, the researchers will have influenced decisions on whether to data share. Our research team and council are all Autistic and very careful to be neurodiversity affirming (pro-Autism). We know that many other Autism researchers say harmful things about Autistic people, and we said this in our information sheet. We also told people to say no if they were worried about any part of data sharing, and that we didn’t mind at all.
On the AASPIRE Outcomes project, over three quarters of people (78%) said yes.
We think this difference might be because on the AASPIRE Outcomes project, only number-based data from a survey were shared, whereas on the AM2M project, people talk a lot about their reproductive health, and their words would be shared.
What did we decide?
We think there should be a lot more safeguards for data sharing in Autism research.
The key thing is that we think people should be able to take part in a study without sharing their answers with other teams (we should use opt in consent).
Government, funders and the online libraries that store shared data should provide education and resources about data sharing. We hope that these will help researchers to do a better job of sharing potential risks and benefits with people before they decide to share their answers.
We also think that on every study, the Autistic community should be involved, to make sure the researchers are doing a good job of describing the risks and benefits.
Where can I find out more?
You can read our paper – including all of our recommendations - for free here: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/13623613261500528
You can also get updates from our study from these places:
Email: AutismM2M@swansea.ac.uk to be added to our mailing list
Instagram: AutismM2M
TiKToK: AutismM2M
